December 12, 2024: France's government "collapsed" Wednesday after Prime Minister Michel Barnier was ousted in a no-confidence vote, with 331 out of 577 lawmakers in the National Assembly voting against him. Appointed by President Emmanuel Macron in September following a contentious parliamentary election, Barnier's exit marks the shortest tenure for a French Prime Minister in modern history, reigniting political turmoil ahead of the new year.
France’s government combines aspects of both parliamentary and presidential systems, creating a unique structure called a semi-presidential republic. It balances power between the President, the Prime Minister, and the National Assembly, giving citizens a direct role in choosing leaders at multiple levels.
How France’s Elections Work
French citizens vote separately for their President and National Assembly representatives.
The President is elected directly through a two-round system, ensuring they have broad public support. If no candidate wins more than 50% of the vote in the first round, the top two candidates compete in a second round. This system allows voters to focus on leadership qualities rather than just party affiliation.
National Assembly representatives, called deputies, are also elected through a two-round system in single-member districts. These elections determine the composition of the Assembly, which works with the Senate (the upper house) to create laws and oversee the government.
Unlike in the British Parliamentary System, where voters elect Members of Parliament (MPs) and the leader of the majority party becomes Prime Minister, French voters separately choose their head of state and legislators. This setup is closer to the U.S. system, where citizens vote for the President and Congress separately.
Who Holds More Power in France?
In France, the President is the most powerful figure, especially when their party controls the National Assembly. The President serves as head of state, oversees foreign and defense policies, appoints the Prime Minister, and can even dissolve the Assembly to call for new elections.
The Prime Minister, chosen by the President but accountable to the Assembly, manages domestic policies and the government’s daily operations. However, the Prime Minister’s power is secondary to the President’s, except during “cohabitation,” when the President’s party does not control the Assembly. In these cases, the Prime Minister may have more influence over domestic matters.
The National Assembly holds legislative power, debating and passing laws and approving the budget. It can also hold the government accountable by voting for a motion of no confidence, which could force the Prime Minister to resign. However, the Assembly’s power is less dominant compared to the UK Parliament, where the government depends entirely on parliamentary support to function.
How France Compares to the British and the U.S. Systems
The French system blends elements of the UK’s parliamentary system and the U.S.’s separation of powers. In the British Parliamentary System, the Prime Minister leads the government and depends on Parliament’s majority support. In the U.S., the President is the sole head of the executive branch, elected independently of Congress. France sits between these systems, with its President as a strong head of state and a Prime Minister linked to Parliament.
Key Differences Between the Three Systems
Election of Leaders:
France: Citizens vote directly for both the President and the National Assembly.
British Parliamentary System: Citizens vote only for MPs, and the majority party leader becomes Prime Minister.
U.S.: Citizens vote separately for the President, Senate, and House of Representatives.
Executive Power:
France: The President holds the most power, but the Prime Minister manages domestic affairs.
British Parliamentary System: The Prime Minister is the most powerful figure, but only with Parliament’s support.
U.S.: The President is the sole executive, with Congress acting as a check on their power.
Legislative Role:
France: The National Assembly can challenge the government but not directly control the President.
British Parliamentary System: Parliament dominates, controlling both legislation and the government’s survival.
U.S.: Congress operates independently of the President, with shared powers between the House and Senate.
This combination of features makes France’s system unique, balancing strong leadership with legislative checks, while allowing citizens to have a direct voice in choosing their leaders.
How France’s Elections Work
Comments